New York Sports | Real Takes

New York Sports | Real Takes

Who Would Be On My 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot

Latest Rants

Email Alerts

Don’t miss any of our rants. Subscribe now for our ICYMI Email Newsletter.

Share :

On Monday, Major League Baseball announced the new ballot for the Baseball Hall of Fame Class of 2027. The ballot includes 27 players — 14 newly eligible players and 13 holdovers. Each member of the BBWAA who receives a ballot can vote for up to 10 players. The Hall of Fame voting results will be announced on January 19, at 6p ET on the MLB Network.

Due to a small technicality — I am not a member of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America — I once again didn’t receive a Hall of Fame ballot. However, that’s not going to stop me from sharing my choices for the 2027 HOF Class.

FIRST-TIME CANDIDATES (WAR)

  1. Jake Arrieta (22.7)
  2. Jay Bruce (19.7)
  3. Asdrubal Cabrera (30.1)
  4. Starlin Castro (18.2)
  5. Wade Davis (10.3)
  6. Brett Gardner (44.3)
  7. Jon Lester (43.4)
  8. Andrew Miller (7.7)
  9. Buster Posey (45.0)
  10. Pablo Sandoval (19.1)
  11. Ervin Santana (27.0)
  12. Kyle Seager (37.0)
  13. Joakim Soria (18.6)
  14. Ryan Zimmerman (40.1)

Candidates must be named on at least 5% of the ballots to remain under consideration again next year. Our Real Take is that 11 of the 14 newly eligible players should be one-and-done. The exceptions are Brett Gardner, Jon Lester, and Buster Posey.

Gardner’s consistency as a table-setter and defender was underappreciated. At the end of the day, he’s not a Hall-of-Famer in my eyes, but I would like him to remain on the ballot so his accomplishments can be discussed at this time every year.

Lester also falls short in my book, but his contributions on three world championship teams — the Boston Red Sox (2007, 2013) and the Chicago Cubs (2016) — give him a chance to eventually earn his induction.

On the other hand, Posey belongs in Cooperstown. Despite playing only 12 seasons, he statistically compares well to recent HOF catchers Joe Mauer, Mike Piazza, and Ivan Rodriguez.

STATSBuster PoseyJoe MauerMike PiazzaIvan Rodriguez
Seasons12151621
Games1,3711,8581,9122,543
Hits1,5002,1232,1272,844
HR158143427311
RBI7299231,3351,332
OBP0.3720.3880.3770.334
OPS0.8310.8270.9220.798
All-Star Games761214
Gold Gloves13013
Playoff Years5455
Championships3001
WAR (bWAR)45.055.659.668.7


HOLDOVER CANDIDATES (WAR)

  1. Bobby Abreu (60.2)
  2. Mark Buehrle (59.0)
  3. Cole Hamels (59.0)
  4. Felix Hernandez (49.8)
  5. Torii Hunter (50.6)
  6. Dustin Pedroia (51.8)
  7. Andy Pettitte (60.2)
  8. Alex Rodriguez (117.4)
  9. Francisco Rodriguez (24.2)
  10. Jimmy Rollins (47.9)
  11. Chase Utley (64.6)
  12. Omar Vizquel (45.6)
  13. David Wright (49.1)

The 13 holdovers all have their supporters. But only three are going to get my vote.

Alex Rodriguez was the best shortstop in baseball when he was a skinny 20-year-old with the Seattle Mariners in 1996. He was still the best SS in baseball when he — supposedly — started taking PEDs with the Texas Rangers in 2001. Finally, he was the best third baseman in baseball for the first 8 of his 12 seasons with the New York Yankees.

Dustin Pedroia and Chase Utley are two world champion second basemen who compare favorably with the two most recent 2B inductees — Craig Biggio and Jeff Kent.

STATSDustin PedroiaChase UtleyCraig BiggioJeff Kent
Seasons14162017
Games1,5121,9372,8502,298
Hits1,8051,8853,0602,461
HR140259291377
RBI7251,0251,1751,518
OBP0.3650.3580.3630.356
OPS0.8050.8230.7960.855
All-Star Games4675
Gold Gloves4040
Playoff Years6867
World Series Championships3100
WAR (bWAR)51.864.665.555.4


THE SRNY BALLOT

Candidates need to receive 75% support to earn induction into the HOF Class of 2027. Here’s a recap of the four players I would be voting for (if they would finally send me a ballot):

  1. Dustin Pedroia (20.7% support last season)
  2. Buster Posey (first-year of eligibility)
  3. Alex Rodriguez (40% support last season)
  4. Chase Utley (59.1% support last season)


ICYMI “Subway Hot Stove: A Mets-Yankees Mock Blockbuster”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top

Email Alerts

Don’t miss any of our rants. Subscribe now for our ICYMI Email Newsletter.

You’re subscribed!

Thanks for signing up, please check your email inbox for our bi-monthly newsletter. Plus, don’t forget to follow-us on your socials @SportsRantNY 

Join Our Newsletter

Sign Up to receive the latest content and breaking news via the SRNY EMAIL ALERTS delivered directly to your inbox.